I wouldn't use the reduced fat food. Most reduced-fat or reduced-calorie diets have quite a bit of excess filler to cut down on calories. Unless the dog has a health condition and can't digest fat, it shouldn't be needed.

~My Handmade Soaps & Body Products~
Silver Maple Soap Company
 imageimageimage
"Handmade Soap is the simplest thing you can do for healthy skin."