AmandaandTuff wrote:
My other pair was great, but that was quite a while ago before I had broken my foot. They fit better, I wore 4 pairs of socks and left them on for a few hours.

Am I reading this right? You shouldn't be able to fit three extra pairs of socks into your boots. They'll never break in properly if they don't actually fit right. I wouldn't soak them, just wear them. It took me a few weeks to break in my current pair of boots to the point where they were comfortable, and they've just gotten better since then.