To the people that suggested trying DnH's Tomato Tea Tree soap- THANK YOU!! After only a week I am so happy! Redness has been reduced so much already, and the oil control is amazing. Normally by noon I'll have had to soak up pools of oil with paper towels at least 3 times; today at about 11:40 I just started noticing a little bit of oil starting to appear. This stuff is awesome and I will totally be spreading the word among other boards I'm part of.

One question though- how often do you use it? So far I've been doing every morning, but I did read that it didn't have to be used every day to get the effects. Just though I'd see what everyone else's routines are.