You can darken it pretty dark with oil. I'd add several more coats and see how dark you can get it. A lot of high end tack is sold light colored, but I've always seen it oiled to a darker color. I usually buy Edgewood and it starts this color, but it's all been able to be oiled to a nice dark brown.

ETA: This is the color I oiled my bridle to:


I didn't need to dye it or anything, I just oiled it. You can do it! Keep oiling!!

Last Edited By: FayeLouise Feb 10 13 6:10 PM. Edited 1 times.