Where are you located? Is that a fair market price? It's sooo not around here. Around here (KY) she might be worth $800. I don't see anything wrong with her really except that she's very skinny. She definitely needs an upgrade. If he's wanting to trade for something that doesn't eat tells me that he's out of feed and or money and won't be getting any more. Hopefully he's desperate enough to take a much lower offer or trade. Good luck!!!