My paint mare LOVES bananas and watermelon. Also popsickles. She eats them real careful if I hold the sticks for her. All 3 of mine go nuts for dry pasta. My neighbor's gelding likes plums and pears. Also bird seed- found out that one on accident- the birds weren't real happy!, peppermint candy, especially the puffy looking ones, dog biscuits. My paint will try anything, her colt is a little more particular. You have to convince him that it is edible. The heathen pony is really picky if I have the food. She will eat about anything the kids give her though.