I really don't see a whole lot wrong with him. I don't like spots, but if I were into Appys I would go have a look at him to see what he's like in person. He is not "perfect", but what is? If he were being advertised as breeding stock it would be a totally different story, but he's a gelding. If you want him just for pleasure riding and fun I don't really see anything horribly wrong with him. Of course seeing him in person may reveal something that is hidden in the picture. Overall I don't think he's worth picking apart completely. He's cute and decent.